Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board: Coat of Arms The
Pennsylvania
Environmental Hearing Board


MENU

Home

About Us

Hearing Schedule

Docket Search

Electronic Filing

Forms

Rules, Decisions, and Resources

EHB Rules Committee

Agency Open Records and "Right to Know" Law

CASE INFORMATION
Case Number: 2011149
Appellant #1: MR. LOREN KISKADDEN

VIEW CASE INFORMATION FOR THIS CASE

CLOSED CASE

# Filing Date Description Documents (?)
1 10-07-2011 Appeal of the Department's September 9, 2011 letter denying his water supply complaint that Range Resources Appalachia LLC's activities did not contaminate his well water supply located at his property in Amwell Township, Washington County.
2 10-11-2011 Notice of Appeal (Exhibit 2 only).
3 10-11-2011 PREHEARING ORDER NO. 1: Discovery completed by April 9, 2012; dispositive motions filed by May 9, 2012.
4 10-11-2011 SUPPLEMENT TO PREHEARING ORDER NO. 1: ELECTRONIC DISCOVERY.
5 10-11-2011 ORDER: This case is selected for the Board's pilot electronic filing program.
6 10-11-2011 ORDER: Appellant has not supplied all of the information required, Appellant shall file on or before October 31, 2011 the following information: 1) Proof of service that NOA was served upon: a) The mining company in appeals involving a claim of subsidence damage or water loss. Amendment as of right expires October 27, 2011.
7 10-13-2011 Department of Environmental Protection's Notice of Appearance for Gail A. Myers and Michael J. Heilman. (e-file)
8 10-13-2011 AMENDED ORDER: Appellant has not supplied all of the information required, Appellant shall file on or before November 2, 2011 the following information: 1) Proof of service that NOA was served upon: a) The well operator in appeals involving a calim of pollution or diminution of a water supply under Section 208 of the Oil and Gas Act. Amendment as of right expires October 27, 2011.
9 10-25-2011 Proof of Service that Notice of Appeal was served upon well operator, Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC. (e-file)
10 01-06-2012 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE: On behalf of the [Department] and Certificate of Service: Richard T. Watling, Esquire, Southwest Region, Office of Chief Counsel, Pittsburgh. (e-file)
11 01-09-2012 Enclosed is the Department's Motion to Dismiss, Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss, Order and Certificate of Service. Exhibit for Motion to Dismiss is being filed electronically with these documents.
12 01-23-2012 Appellant Kiskadden's Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss. (e-file)
13 02-01-2012 Notice of Appearance filed on behalf of [Permittee] Jeremy A. Mercer, Esquire, Fulbright & Jaworski, LLP, Canonsburg, Pa. (e-file)
14 02-07-2012 Department's Memorandum of Law in Reply to Appellant's Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Appellee's Motion to Dismiss and Proof of Service. (e-file)
15 03-14-2012 Department of Environmental Protection's Motion for Protective Order to Prevent Deposition of Department Counsel, Certification Required Pursuant to 25 Pa. Code Section 1021.93(b), Proposed Order and Certificate of Service. (e-file)
16 03-14-2012 Department of Environmental Protection's Memorandum in Support of its Motion for Protective Order. (e-file)
17 03-15-2012 ORDER: It is ordered: 1) The deposition of Attorney Myers scheduled for March 16, 2012 is postponed. 2) Appellant's response and Memorandum of Law in support of its response filed by March 29, 2012. 3) Permittee may also file a response by March 29, 2012.
18 03-26-2012 Department's letter serving as Consensual Request for Stay of Discovery and of Pre-Hearing and Briefing Deadlines, Order and Proof of Service. (e-file)
19 03-28-2012 Appellant Kiskadden's Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Department of Environmental Protection's Motion for Protective Order. (e-file)
20 03-29-2012 Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Memorandum of Law in Support of the Department of Environmental Protection's Motion for Protective Order. (e-file)
21 04-03-2012 ORDER: It is ordered: 1) Consensual report is denied. 2) Discovery extended until June 15, 2012; and 3) Dispositive motions filed by July 25, 2012.
22 04-11-2012 ORDER: It is ordered that the Board's Order April 3, 2012 is vacated. All prehearing deadlines pending discovery and depositions are stayed for 60 days from the date of this Order.
23 04-20-2012 Department's Motion for Statement of Fact In Motion for Protective Order to Be Deemed Admitted & Issuance of Protective or, In the Alternative, Motion for Leave to Reply to Appellants Memorandum in Opposition to DEP's Motion for Protective Order, Certificate of Service and Exhibits attached hereto electronically
24 04-20-2012 ORDER: Department's motion for leave to file reply is denied.
25 05-16-2012 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION TO DISMISS: Department's motion to dismiss is denied.
26 05-17-2012 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER: It is ordered: Department's motion for protective order is granted. Appellant is prohibited from deposing Attorney Gail Myers.
27 05-25-2012 Joint Status Report. (e-file)
28 06-11-2012 ORDER: It is ordered: 1) Parties shall file a report pursuant to the Board's Order of October 11, 2011 on or before June 30, 2012. 2) Responses to any pending discovery due on July 25, 2012. 3) Discovery completed by October 1, 2012. 4) Dispositive motions filed by November 1, 2012. 5) Responses to dispositive motions filed by December 1, 2012.
29 07-02-2012 Appellant Kiskadden's Proposed Report Concerning the Discovery of Electronically Stored Information. (e-file)
30 07-03-2012 Department's letter serving as joint request to extend period for parties to submit ESI Report to the Board, Order and Proof of Service. (e-file)
31 07-05-2012 ORDER: It is ordered that the parties shall jointly file their ESI report on or before July 12, 2012.
32 07-12-2012 Department's letter, Draft Report Concerning ESI and Proof of Service. (e-file)
33 08-17-2012 ORDER: Status conference is scheduled for August 29, 2012 at 10:30 am at the EHB Pittsburgh office.
34 08-29-2012 ORDER: It is ordered: 1) Proposed report concerning the discovery of electronically stored information filed with the Board on July 12, 2012 is adopted with the following additions or revisions (see a through f). 2) Counsel shall file a joint status report on or before October 17, 2012.
35 08-30-2012 ORDER: Discovery completed by November 21, 2012; dispositive motions filed by December 7, 2012; and responses to dispositive motions filed by January 7, 2013.
36 10-05-2012 Appellant Kiskadden Motion to Compel. (e-file)
37 10-05-2012 Appellant Kiskadden Motion to Enforce/Ensure "Litigation Hold" on the Yeager Drill Site and for Expedited Consideration Thereof
38 10-05-2012 ORDER: Appellant's motion for expedited consideration is granted. If Permittee and Department wish to respond to motion to enforce/ensure litigation hold on the Yeager Drill site, they shall do so on or before October 11, 2012.
39 10-09-2012 Appellant Kiskadden Motion to Compel "exhibits".
40 10-09-2012 Appellant Kiskadden Motion to Compel Exhibit 7.
41 10-09-2012 Appellant Kiskadden Motion to Compel Exhibits 8-9.
42 10-09-2012 Appellant Kiskadden Motion to Compel Exhibits 10-17.
43 10-10-2012 Appellant Kiskadden Motion to Compel Exhibits 1-6.
44 10-11-2012 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE: filed on behalf of [Permittee] Matthew H. Sepp, Esquire with Fulbright & Jaworski, LLP, Canonsburg, Pa. (e-file)
45 10-11-2012 ORDER: It is ordered: Board will conduct a site view in Washington County at the Yeager Drill Site and on the Kiskadden property on October 19, 2012 at 10:45 am.
46 10-11-2012 Deparment's Response to Appellant's Motion to Enforce/Ensure Litigation Hold on the Yeager Drill site with Exhibit A as being filed electronically, Memorandum in Support of the Department's Response and Proof of Service. (e-file)
47 10-11-2012 Permittee Range Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Answer to Appellant Loren Kiskadden's Motion to Enforce / Ensure "Litigation Hold" on the Yeager Drill and for Expedited Consideration Thereof. (e-file)
48 10-11-2012 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Brief in Support of Answer to Appellant Loren Kiskadden's Motion to Enforce / Ensure "Litigation Hold" on the Yeager Drill Site and for Expedited Consideration Thereof. (e-file)
49 10-12-2012 Permittee Range Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Answer to Appellant Loren Kiskadden's Motion to Enforce / Ensure "Litigation Hold" on the Yeager Drill and for Expedited Consideration Thereof. (hard)
50 10-12-2012 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Brief in Support of Answer to Appellant Loren Kiskadden's Motion to Enforce / Ensure "Litigation Hold" on the Yeager Drill Site and for Expedited Consideration Thereof (w/exhibits). (hard)
51 10-16-2012 Appellant Kiskadden's Response to October 11, 2012 Court Order. (e-file)
52 10-16-2012 Department's letter regarding Board's site visit to Appellant's real property. (e-file)
53 10-16-2012 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response to October 11, 2012 Order and Appellant's Response Thereto. (e-file)
54 10-17-2012 ORDER: EHB's Board's Order of October 11, 2012 is revised as follows: 1) All persons taking part in the site view shall meet at the office of Range Resources at 10:30 am on October 19, 2012 to participate in the safety training. 2) Following training, all persons participating in the site view will meet at the appellant's property. 3)...Permittee's request that the Board view the interior of the appellant's house is denied.
55 10-17-2012 Joint Status Report. (e-file)
56 10-17-2012 Amended Notice of Appearance On Behalf of Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC - Megan E. Smith, Esquire, Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney PC. (e-file)
57 10-23-2012 PREHEARING ORDER NO. 2: Hearing scheduled for April 16, 2013 through April 25, 2013 at 9:30 a.m. The hearing will be held at the Pittsburgh Office of the EHB, 310 Piatt Place, 301 Fifth Avenue, Second Floor, Hearing Room 2014, Pittsburgh. (Adelman Reporters) 1) Appellant's PreHearing Memorandum filed by February 20, 2013. 2) Department and Permittee's PreHearing Memoranda filed by March 7, 2013. 3) Motions in limine filed by March 14, 2013; Responses filed by March 22, 2013.
58 10-23-2012 Department's Response to Appellants's Motion to Compel Discovery Responses and Memorandum in Support and Proof of Service. Exhibits for Department's Motion to Compel attached hereto electronically. (e-file)
59 11-05-2012 Withdrawal of Appearance on behalf of [Permittee]: Megan E. Smith, Esquire with Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney, PC, Pittsburgh. (e-file)
60 11-06-2012 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion for Protective Order and for Expedited Consideration Thereof. (e-file)
61 11-06-2012 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION TO ENFORCE/ENSURE "LITIGATION HOLD" ON THE YEAGER DRILL SITE AND FOR EXPEDITED CONSIDERATION THEREOF: It is ordered as follows: 1) By Order of October 5, 2012, we granted the appellant's request for expedited consideration of its motion to enforce. 2) Appellant's motion to enforce/ensure "Litigation Hold" on the Yeager Drill Site is denied. 3) Range Resources' request for counsel fees in responding to the motion to enforce is denied.
62 11-06-2012 ORDER: Conference call is scheduled with counsel for today, November 6, 2012 at 4:15 pm.
63 11-06-2012 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Extend Discovery. (e-file)
64 11-06-2012 Department of Environmental Protection's Response to Appellant's Motion for Protective Order and for Expedited Consideration Thereof. (e-file)
65 11-06-2012 Department's Memorandum in support of its Response to Appellant's Motion for Protective Order and for Expedited Consideration Thereof. (e-file)
66 11-08-2012 ORDER: Discovery is extended to January 22, 2013.
67 11-08-2012 ORDER: Appellant's motion for protective order seeking to preclude Alan Eichler from attending depositions of the Department employees is denied.
68 11-09-2012 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion for Protective Order to Prohibit Video Recording. (e-file)
69 11-09-2012 ORDER on Motion to Compel 1 through 9.
70 11-09-2012 ORDER: Following review of appellant's motion for protective order to prohibit video recording, it is ordered: 1) Permittee and Department may file responses before 2:00 pm on November 13, 2012.
71 11-13-2012 Department's letter stating will not be filing a response to Appellant's Motion for Protective Order. (e-file)
72 11-13-2012 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Answer to Motion for Protective Order and For Expedited Consideration Thereof. (e-file)
73 11-13-2012 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Memorandum of Law in Support of Answer to Motion for Protective Order and for Expedited Consideration Thereof. (e-file)
74 11-13-2012 ORDER: It is ordered: 1) Motion for protective order is granted. 2) Range Resources is prohibited from utilizing a videographer at any deposition taken...4) All depositions after November 25, 2012 shall take place in a conference call at Piatt Place, 301 5th Ave., Pittsburgh. 5) Deposition notices shall be filed on the Board's electronic docket.
75 11-14-2012 Appellant Kiskadden's Objection to Request for Entry Upon Property. (e-file)
76 11-15-2012 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Richard Thomas Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1 (e-file)
77 11-21-2012 Notice of Deposition of Richard Thomas. (e-file)
78 11-26-2012 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Richard Thomas Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
79 11-27-2012 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Michael C. Steindorf. (e-file)
80 11-27-2012 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Tyler H. Lipp. (e-file)
81 11-27-2012 ORDER: Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Michael C. Steindorf, Esquire on behalf of Permittee is granted.
82 11-27-2012 ORDER: Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Tyler H. Lipp, Esquire on behalf of Permittee is granted.
83 11-30-2012 Notice of Deposition of Bryon Miller. (e-file)
84 11-30-2012 Notice of Deposition of Michael Morgart. (e-file)
85 11-30-2012 Notice of Deposition of Vincent Yantko. (e-file)
86 11-30-2012 Notice of Deposition of Ed Bates. (e-file)
87 11-30-2012 Notice of Deposition of Alan Eichler. (e-file)
88 11-30-2012 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Ed Bates Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
89 12-03-2012 Appellant Kiskadden Motion to Extend Deadline for Dispositive Motions and for Expedited Consideration Thereof. (e-file)
90 12-03-2012 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Michael Morgart Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
91 12-03-2012 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Bryon Miller Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
92 12-03-2012 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Alan Eichler Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
93 12-03-2012 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Vincent Yantko Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
94 12-03-2012 Appellant Kiskadden Motion to Compel Discovery from Permittee, Range Resources. (e-file)
95 12-04-2012 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE: On behalf of [Appellant]: John M. Smith, Esquire, Smith Butz, LLC, Canonsburg, Pa. (e-file)
96 12-05-2012 ORDER: Motion to extend deadline for dispositive motions is granted-in-part. Dispositive motions filed by January 10, 2013; responses to any dispositive motions filed by February 11, 2013; and replies to responses filed by February 26, 2013,
97 12-07-2012 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Motion for Order Authorizing Entry Upon Property of Appellant. (e-file)
98 12-10-2012 ORDER: It is ordered: ...2) Oral argument will be held at 2:00 pm on December 20, 2012 at the EHB Pittsburgh office. (Adelman Reporters) 3) Appellant shall file his response to permittee's motion for order authorizing entry upon property of appellant by December 19, 2012.
99 12-18-2012 Department's letter regarding no objection to Range's Order Authorizing Entry Upon Property of Appellant and Proof of Service. (e-file)
100 12-18-2012 December 18, 2012 Letter from K. Komoroski to Judge Renwand. (e-file)
101 12-19-2012 Appellant Kiskadden's Response to Motion for Order Authorizing Entry. (e-file)
102 12-19-2012 December 19, 2012 Letter from K. Komoroski to Judge Renwand. (e-file)
103 12-28-2012 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Strike Errata Sheets and Memorandum of Law in Support; proposed order. (e-file)
104 12-31-2012 Amended Notice of Deposition of Vincent Yantko. (e-file)
105 12-31-2012 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Strike Errata Sheets and Memorandum of Law in Support; along with "exhibits." (hard)
106 01-02-2013 Amended Cross-Notice of Deposition of Vincent Yantko Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
107 01-07-2013 Department's Letter, Motion to Strike Appellant Lorden kiskadden's Motion to Strike Errata Sheets, Memorandum in Support thereof, proposed Order, and Certificate of Service. (e-file)
108 01-08-2013 Appellant Loren Kiskadden's Letter in Response to the Department's Motion to Strike. (e-file)
109 01-08-2013 ORDER: It is ordered: 1) Appellant shall file an amended motion to strike errata sheets and supporting memorandum that comply with the Board's rules of practice and procedure. 2) Appellant is not required to resubmit his exhibits in support of amended motion. 3) Opposing parties have 15 days from service of the amended motion in which to respond.
110 01-10-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment, Statement of Undisputed Material Facts and Brief in Support. (e-file)
111 01-11-2013 January 11, 2013 Letter from Kenneth Komoroski, Esq. to Judge Renwand re: Permittee's Motion for Order Authorizing Entry Upon Property of Appellant. (e-file)
112 01-11-2013 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Loretta Logsdon Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
113 01-11-2013 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Grace Kiskadden Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
114 01-11-2013 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Loren Kiskadden Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
115 01-11-2013 Department's letter Pursuant to Board's Order dated November 13, 2012 enclosed with Notices of Depositions and Proof of Services. (e-file)
116 01-11-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Amended Notice of Deposition of Vincent Yantko. (e-file)
117 01-11-2013 Amended Cross-Notice of Deposition of Vincent Yantko Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1 (e-file)
118 01-14-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment, Statement of Undisputed Material Facts and Brief in Support of with Volume I, Exhibits 1-38; Volume II, Exhibits 30-67; Volume III, Exhibits 68-84; Volume IV, Exhibits 85-104. (hard)
119 01-16-2013 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION FOR ORDER AUTHORIZING ENTRY UPON PROPERTY OF APPELLANT: It is ordered as follows: 1) The motion for entry is granted in part and denied in part. (Please see Order for numbers 2 through 13)
120 01-18-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Extend Case Deadlines and for Expedited Consideration Thereof. (e-file)
121 01-24-2013 Departments Joint Request for Extension of Time and Proceedings letter, Order and Proof of Service. (e-file)
122 01-24-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Amended Motion to Strike Errata Sheets and Memorandum of Law. (e-file)
123 01-24-2013 ORDER: Upon consideration of appellant's motion to extend case deadlines and upon consideration of the joint requests made by the parties, it is ordered: 1) Appellant's request to extend discovery to March 31, 2013 is granted with respect to the following: (See Order for further details and nos. 2 thru 5)
124 01-25-2013 AMENDED PREHEARING ORDER NO. 2: Hearing is rescheduled for June 12, 2013 and continuing on June 13, 14, 17, 18, 19 & 20, 2013 at 9:30 a.m. (Adelman Reporters) The hearing will be held at the Pittsburgh Office of the EHB, Piatt Place, 301 Fifth Avenue, Second Floor, Hearing Room 2014, Pittsburgh. 1) Appellant's PreHearing Memorandum filed by April 9 2013. 2) Department and Permittee's PreHearing Memoranda filed by April 24, 2013. 3) Motions in limine filed by May 1, 2013; Responses filed by May 9, 2013...8) Prehearing conference scheduled for June 7, 2013 at 10:00 am at the EHB Board's Pittsburgh office.
125 01-30-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Conduct Sampling Upon Property of Permittee and proposed order. (e-file)
126 02-06-2013 Department's Response to Appellant's Motion to Strike Errata Sheets, Exhibts attached for Motion attached hereto, Memorandum in Support of Motion to Strike, Order and Proof of Service. (e-file)
127 02-07-2013 Department's Response to Appellant's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment, Satement of Undisputed Facts and Brief in Support of and Proof of Service. Exhibits A-E for Brief in Support will be sent under separate cover through US Postal Service due to the size exceeing the Board's limit. (e-file)
128 02-08-2013 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Request for Leave to Exceed the Five-Page Limit for Its Response to Appellant's Statement of Undisputed Material Facts
129 02-08-2013 ORDER: It is ordered that the request for leave is granted. Permittee's response to appellant's statement of undisputed material facts may not exceed 15 pages in length.
130 02-11-2013 Department's Response to Appellant's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment, Satement of Undisputed Facts and Brief in Support of and Proof of Service. Exhibits A-E for Brief in Support will be sent under separate cover through US Postal Service due to the size exceeing the Board's limit. (hard)
131 02-11-2013 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment. (e-file)
132 02-11-2013 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Statement of Undisputed Material Facts. (e-file)
133 02-11-2013 Brief in Support of Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and Statement of Undisputed Material Facts. (e-file)
134 02-11-2013 Index of Exhibits in Support of: (1) Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Statement of Undisputed Material Facts; and (2) Brief in Support of Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and Statement of Undisputed Material Facts. (e-file)
135 02-14-2013 ORDER: Telephone conference scheduled for February 15, 2013 at 9:30 am.
136 02-14-2013 Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's copy of exhibits A-Q of its electronic filing on February 11, 2013 (1) Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Statement of Undisputed Material Facts; and (2) Brief in Support of Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and Statement of Undisputed Material Facts. (hard)
137 02-14-2013 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response in Opposition to Appellant's Motion to Conduct Sampling Upon Property of Permittee, and proposed order. (e-file)
138 02-14-2013 Brief in Support of Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion to Conduct Sampling upon Property of Permittee, and Exhibits 1-6. (e-file)
139 02-18-2013 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Request for Leave to Conduct Supplemental Depositions. (e-file)
140 02-21-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Response to Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Request for Leave to Conduct Supplemental. (e-file) Depositions
141 02-26-2013 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION TO STRIKE ERRATA SHEETS: Appellant's amended motion to strike errata sheets is denied.
142 02-26-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Reply Brief in Support of Motion for Partial Summary Judgment
143 02-26-2013 OPINION AND ORDER ON DENYING MOTION TO REOPEN DISCOVERY: It is ordered Motion is denied.
144 02-27-2013 February 27, 2013 Letter to the Honorable Thomas W. Renwand Withdrawing Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Opposition to Appellant's Motion to Conduct Sampling Upon Property of Permittee. (e-file)
145 03-04-2013 Notice of Deposition for Alan Eichler. (e-file)
146 03-06-2013 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Alan Eichler Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1
147 03-06-2013 Letter from Attorney Kenneth Komoroski to Judge Renwand. (e-file)
148 03-07-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion for Order Seeking Litigation Hold. (e-file)
149 03-08-2013 Department's letter regarding scope of ordered re-depositions and Proof of Service. (e-file)
150 03-11-2013 Letter from Kenneth Komoroski to Judge Renwand. (e-file)
151 03-22-2013 ORDER: It is ordered: 1) Counsel are granted permission to depose Mr. Eichler at a mutually convenient time in June 2013 in the Board's Pittsburgh Court Room. 2) Counsel shall advise the Board of the deposition dates. 3) Counsel shall exchange expert reports on dates they agree to in June 2013.
152 03-22-2013 ORDER: The hearing scheduled for June 12, 2013 through June 20, 2013 is cancelled. (Adelman Reporters)
153 03-22-2013 SECOND AMENDED PREHEARING ORDER NO. 2: Hearing is rescheduled for OCTOBER 16, 2013 and continuing on October 17, 18, 22, 23 & 24, 2013 at 9:30 a.m. (Adelman Reporters) The hearing will be held at the Pittsburgh Office of the EHB, Piatt Place, 301 Fifth Avenue, Second Floor, Hearing Room 2014, Pittsburgh. 1) Appellant's PreHearing Memorandum filed by July 10, 2013. 2) Department and Permittee's PreHearing Memoranda filed by July 25, 2013. 3) Motions in limine filed by August 15, 2013; Responses filed by August 26, 2013.
154 03-25-2013 NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE: On behalf of the [Department] Gail A. Myers in the Loren Kiskadden case. (e-file)
155 03-27-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice of Deposition of John Carson. (e-file)
156 03-27-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice of Deposition of Taru Upadhyay. (e-file)
157 03-28-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Renew Motion to Compel. (e-file)
158 04-03-2013 Cross-Notice of Deposition of John Carson Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
159 04-03-2013 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Taru Upadhyay Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1 (e-file)
160 04-09-2013 Letter to Judge Renwand from Attorney Smith. (e-file)
161 04-09-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Compel Discovery from Permittee, Range Resources; proposed order. (e-file)
162 04-10-2013 Letter from Kenneth Komoroski to Judge Renwand. (e-file)
163 04-10-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Compel Discovery from DEP; proposed order; supporting exhibits 1, 2, and 3-5. (e-file)
164 04-12-2013 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response in Opposition to Appellant's Motion to Renew Motion to Compel. (e-file)
165 04-16-2013 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Uncontested Motion to Extend Time to Complete the Deposition of Taru Upadhyay, with Certificate of Concurrence and Proposed Order. (e-file)
166 04-16-2013 ORDER: The time period to complete the deposition of taru Upadhyay is extended to May 30, 2013.
167 04-22-2013 Amended Notice of Deposition of Taru Upadhyay. (e-file)
168 04-22-2013 Permittee, Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Uncontested Motion to Extend Time to Complete the Deposition of John Carson. (e-file)
169 04-24-2013 ORDER: The time period to complete the deposition of John Carson is extended to May 30, 2013.
170 04-24-2013 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Response in Opposition to Appellant's Motion to Compel Discovery Responses
171 04-25-2013 Department's Response to Appellant's Motion To Compel Discovery Responses,Memorandum in Support thereof, Order and Proof of Service. (e-file) Due to Exhibits A-H exceeding Board's limits, the Department will be sending Exhibits through US Mail.
172 04-29-2013 Department's Response to Appellant's Motion To Compel Discovery Responses,Memorandum in Support thereof, Order and Proof of Service w/Exhibits A-H original and one copy. (hard)
173 04-30-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Amended Notice of Deposition of John Carson. (e-file)
174 05-01-2013 Cross-Notice of Deposition of John Carson Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
175 05-01-2013 Cross-Notice of Deposition fo Taru Upadhyay Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
176 05-09-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Amended Notice of Deposition of John Carson. (e-file)
177 05-23-2013 Cross-Notice of Deposition of John Carson Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1. (e-file)
178 05-30-2013 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Motion to Compel Production of Water Testing Data. (e-file)
179 06-03-2013 ORDER: Oral argument will take place in Court Room 2014 in Piatt Place, Pittsburgh, PA on Thursday, June 13, 2013 at 10:00 am. (Adelman Reporters)
180 06-05-2013 ORDER: The oral argument scheduled for June 13, 2013 at 10:00 am is cancelled. The oral argument after consultation with all counsel, will be held on June 21, 2013 at 10:15 am.
181 06-06-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Response to Range Resources' Motion to Compel Production of Water Testing Data. (e-file)
182 06-11-2013 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE: filed on behalf of [Permittee], Steven E.H. Gibbs, Esquire, of Fulbright & Jaworski, LLP, Canonsburg, PA. (e-file)
183 06-25-2013 Proposed Order of Court Regarding Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Renew Motion to Compel
184 06-25-2013 Proposed Order of Court Regarding Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Compel Discovery from Permittee
185 06-25-2013 Proposed Order of Court Regarding Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Compel Discovery from DEP
186 06-26-2013 Department's submission of Proposed Order Regarding Appellant's Motion to Compel Discovery Response from DEP, Certificate of Service. Exhibit A is also attached hereto.
187 06-26-2013 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's letter to the Board enclosing proposed orders (Exhibits A-C also are attached hereto)
188 06-28-2013 Joint Proposed Case Management Order
189 07-02-2013 ORDER: It is ordered: 1) Request to reschedule the hearing in this case from October 2013 until May 2014 is granted. (Adelman Reporters) 2) Dates of the hearing and any prehearing deadlines will be set forth in a separate Order.
190 07-12-2013 Amended Notice of Deposition for Taru Upadhyay
191 07-12-2013 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Taru Upadhyay Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4017.1
192 07-12-2013 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE: Dennis St. J. Mulvihill, Bruce E. Rende and Erin J. Dolfi as co-counsel for Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC
193 07-12-2013 ORDER: Following review of the joint proposed case management order, it is ordered: 1) Expert reports shall be exchanged by December 10, 2013. ...3) Appellant's prehearing memo due by February 3, 2014. 4) Department and Permittee shall file their prehearing memos by February 18, 2014. ...7) Hearing is scheduled beginning May 6, 2014 and continuing May 7, 8, 9, 13, 14, 15, and 16, 2014 at 9:30 am in Hearing Room 2014, Piatt Place, Pittsburgh. (Adelman Reporters)
194 07-18-2013 ORDER: Appellant's motion to compel discovery responses seeking the production of all QA/QC data accompanying testing performed during the 2008-2009 Department study is denied.
195 07-18-2013 ORDER - on Permittee's motion to compel production of water testing date from appellant and appellant's response.
196 07-19-2013 ORDER: After review of Appellant's Motion to Compel Discovery Responses from Permittee and Appellant's Motion to Renew Motion to Compel Against Permittee, Permittee's Responses, and following Oral Argument before the Board, it is ordered as follows... 9) Appellant's Motion to Renew Motion to Compel is granted.
197 07-22-2013 ORDER: It is ordered..3) Appellant's motion for partial summary judgment is denied.
198 07-22-2013 WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE: On behalf of [Permittee, Range Resources] Jeremy A. Mercer, Esquire, Fulbright & Jaworski, LLP.
199 07-30-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Compel Discovery Responses from Appellee, Department of Environmental Protection
200 08-09-2013 Department's letter requesting five (5) day extenstion to Respond to Appellant's pending Motion to Compel directed to the Department, Order and Proof of Service.
201 08-09-2013 ORDER: Department's time to respond to appellant's motion to compel discovery responses , it is hereby extended by five days to and including Monday, August 19, 2013.
202 08-13-2013 Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Request for Status Conference and Clarification Regarding the Board's Order Dated July 19, 2013
203 08-19-2013 Department's Response to Appellant's Motion to Compel Discovery Responses, Certificate of Service and Exhibits A-D attached hereto.
204 09-17-2013 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion for Contempt and for Sanctions in the Form of An Adverse Inference
205 10-02-2013 Department's Response to Appellants Motion for Contempt and For Sanctions in the Form of an Adverse Inference, Proof of Service and Exhibits A-H will be filed under separate cover to due exceeding the Boards limit.
206 10-02-2013 Permittee Range Resources – APPALACHIA, LLC’S Response to Appellant's Motion for Contempt and for Sanctions in the Form of an Adverse Inference. (w/exhibits A thru D)
207 10-02-2013 Brief in Support of Permittee Range Resources - APPALACHIA, LLC’S Response to Appellant's Motion for Contempt and for Sanctions in the Form of an Adverse Interfence. (w/Exhibits A thru K)
208 10-02-2013 Exhibit L - to its Brief in Support of Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC Response to Appellant's Motion for Contempt and for Sanction
209 10-24-2013 Notice of Change of Address for Co-Counsel of Record for Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC
210 10-24-2013 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE: On behalf of [Permittee] - Maxine M. Woelfling, Esquire, of Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP, Harrisburg, PA.
211 11-15-2013 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Status Report
212 11-20-2013 ORDER: Appellant's motion to compel is denied.
213 11-26-2013 Joint Proposed Case Management Order
214 11-26-2013 ORDER: The Board has made some modifications to the joint proposed case management order: 1) Deposition of Mr. Eichler shall take place on or before January 31, 2014...3) Appellant's prehearing memo filed by March 12, 2014. 4) Department and Permittee's prehearing memos filed by March 27, 2014. 5) Motions in limine filed by April 7, 2014. 6) Responses to motions in limine filed by April 17, 2014. 7) Hearing remains as previously scheduled.
215 12-31-2013 Amended Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum of Alan Eichler
216 01-03-2014 Cross-Notice of Deposition of Alan Eichler
217 01-29-2014 ORDER: It is ordered: 1) Expert reports shall be exchanged by April 3, 2014. 2) Appellant's prehearing memorandum filed by April 9, 2014. 3) Department and Permittee's prehearing memos filed by April 24, 2014. 4) Motions in limine by May 7, 2014. 5) Responses to motions in limine by May 15, 2014. 6) Hearing rescheduled to begin at 9:30 am on May 28, 29, 30, June 3, 4, 5, 6 and if needed June 9, 2014 at the EHB Pittsburgh location. (Adelman Reporters)
218 01-31-2014 ORDER: It is ordered: 1) The third and final day of Mr. Eichler's deposition will take place on Monday, February 3, 2014. 2) Deposition will begin at 8:30 am and conclude no later than 5:00 pm.
219 02-06-2014 WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE: On behalf of [Permittee] Michael Steindorf, Esquire and Tyler Lipp, Esquire, Fulbright & Jaworski, LLP, Dallas, Texas.
220 03-11-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Letter to Judge Renwand
221 03-17-2014 ORDER: Telephone status conference will be held with counsel on March 27, 2014 at 10:15 a.m.
222 03-19-2014 ORDER: Telephone status conference with counsel is scheduled on March 27, 2014 at 2:00 p.m.
223 03-28-2014 ORDER: All prehearing deadlines are stayed. Status conference is scheduled with counsel on May 7, 2014 at 2:00 pm at the EHB Pittsburgh office.
224 04-17-2014 ORDER: It is ordered: 1) Prehearing deadlines are postponed. 2) Hearing scheduled for late May and June 2014 is postponed. (Adelman Reporters)
225 05-02-2014 May 2, 2014 Letter to the Honorable Thomas W. Renwand
226 05-02-2014 Department's Letter stating no objection to re-scheduling May 7, 2014 status conference and POS
227 05-05-2014 May 5, 2014 Letter to the Honorable Judge Renwand
228 05-05-2014 ORDER: It is ordered as follows: 1) Following a careful review of the request and responses, the request to reschedule the prehearing conference is denied... 3) Hearings for this case has been rescheduled several times. 8)The main purpose for the prehearing conference on May 7, 2014 is to schedule prehearing filing dates and hearing dates. 9) The hearing dates arrived at with Counsel on May 7, 2014 will not be extended absent exigent circumstances. 10) The Board will not be hearing oral argument on any other issues during the prehearing conference on May 7, 2014.
229 05-07-2014 Letter to the Honorable Thomas W. Renwand
230 05-09-2014 THIRD AMENDED PREHEARING ORDER NO. 2: Hearing is rescheduled for September 23 and continuing on September 24, 25, 30 and October 1, 2, 3, 7, 8 and 9, 2014 at 10:00 a.m. (Adelman Reporters) Second Floor, Hearing Room 2014, Piatt Place, 301 Fifth Avenue, Pittsburgh. 1) All parties shall file their expert reports by July 10, 2014. 2) Appellant's preHearing memo filed by August 11, 2014. 3) Department and Permittee's prehearing memos filed by August 26, 2014. 4) Motions in limine filed by September 3, 2014. Responses filed by September 10, 2014... 9) Prehearing conference scheduled for September 16, 2014 at 10:15 a.m. at the EHB Piatt Place, Room 310, Pittsburgh.
231 05-09-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Letter to the Honorable Judge Renwand
232 05-14-2014 ORDER: On May 13, 2014, Counsel for Range Resources filed a letter requesting the extension of prehearing deadlines in the appeal filed at EHB Docket No. 2013-112-R...By this Order the Board is transferring the filing to the correct docket number and striking it from this docket number.
233 05-28-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Supplemental Brief in Support of Motion for Adverse Inference
234 06-04-2014 Department's Supplemental Response to Appellant's Motion and Proof of Service
235 06-04-2014 Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Reply to Appellant's Supplemental Brief in Support of Motion for Contempt and for Sanctions in the Form of an Adverse Inference
236 06-06-2014 "Exhibit C" of Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Reply to Appellant's Supplemental Brief in Support of Motion for Contempt and for Sanctions in the Form of an Adverse Inference.
237 06-06-2014 "Exhibit C" of Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Reply to Appellant's Supplemental Brief in Support of Motion for Contempt and for Sanctions in the Form of an Adverse Inference. (scan)
238 06-10-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION FOR CONTEMPT AND FOR SANCTIONS IN THE FORM OF AN ADVERSE INFERENCE: It is ordered that the Appellant's motion for contempt and for sanctions is denied in part and granted in part.
239 07-07-2014 Motion for Determination of Scope of Rebuttable Presumption in Opinion and Order dated June 10, 2014 and for Entry of an Order Directing Appellant to Disclose Alleged Contaminants in his Water Supply
240 07-07-2014 Brief in Support of Motion for Determination of Scope of Rebuttable Presumption in Opinion and Order dated June 10, 2014 and for Entry of an Order Directing Appellant to Disclose Alleged Contaminants in his Water Supply
241 07-09-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Stay Pre-Hearing Deadlines and For Expedited Consideration Thereof
242 07-10-2014 ORDER: Appellant's motion to stay prehearing deadlines is denied.
243 07-10-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's Submittal of Expert Reports
244 07-10-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Expert Report 1 - Paul A. Rubin
245 07-10-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Expert Report 2 - Michael A. Sommer II, Ph.D.
246 07-10-2014 Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Expert Report
247 07-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Response to Range Motion for Determination of Scope of Rebuttable Presumption in Opinion and Order dated June 10, 2014 and for Entry of an Order Directing Appellant to Disclose Alleged Contaminants in his Water Supply
248 07-21-2014 Department's Response to Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion For Determination Of Scope Of Rebuttable Presumption In Opinion And Order Dated June 10, 2014 and for Entry Of An Order Directing Appellant To Disclose Alleged Contaminants In His Water Supply, Exhibit A, and Certificate of Service
249 08-06-2014 Notice of Supplemental Authority Concerning Motion for Determination of Scope of Rebuttable Presumption
250 08-06-2014 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE filed on behalf of [Permittee]: John K. Gisleson, Esquire, at Morgan, Lewis & Bockis, LLP, Pittsburgh, PA.
251 08-06-2014 Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Motion to Compel Sampling of Appellant's Water Supply and For Expedited Consideration Thereof
252 08-07-2014 ORDER: Mr. Kiskadden and the Department may file responses to Range Resources' Notice of Supplemental Authority Concerning Motion for Determination of Scope of Rebuttable Presumption on or before August 21, 2014.
253 08-11-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Pre-Hearing Memorandum (Exhibits sent via mail)
254 08-12-2014 Appellant's "Exhibits" to its Prehearing Memorandum. (4 boxes). Courtesy set of exhibits were mailed to Judge Renwand in Pittsburgh.
255 08-13-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Notice to Attend Directed to Appellant Kiskadden
256 08-15-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Response and Objection to Range Motion to Compel Sampling of Appellant's Water Supply
257 08-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice to Attend Directed to Taru Upadhyay
258 08-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice to Attend Directed to John Carson
259 08-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice to Attend Directed to Bryon Miller
260 08-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice to Attend Directed to Vince Yantko
261 08-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice to Attend Directed to Alan Eichler
262 08-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice to Attend Directed to Michael Morgart
263 08-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice to Attend Directed to Edward Bates
264 08-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice to Attend Directed to Glenn Truzzi, P.E.
265 08-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice to Attend Directed to Pete Miller
266 08-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Notice to Attend Directed to Eric Gustafson
267 08-19-2014 Department's Letter, Notice to Attend directed to Mr. Loren Kiskadden, and Certificate of Service.
268 08-21-2014 DEP's Letter not opposing Range Resources request to conduct sampling.
269 08-21-2014 DEP's Response to Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Notice of Supplemental Authority Concerning Motion for Determination of Scope of Rebuttable Presumption, and Certificate of Service.
270 08-21-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Response to Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Notice of Supplemental Authority Concerning Motion for Determination of Scope of Rebuttable Presumption
271 08-22-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Submission of Expert Report of Tarek Saba, Ph.D.
272 08-22-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Submission of Rebuttal Expert Report of Samuel A. Flewelling, Ph.D.
273 08-26-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Submission of Rebuttal Expert Report of Scott A. Stout, Ph.D., P.G.
274 08-26-2014 DEP's Letter, Pre-Hearing Memorandum, Exhibit A (Exhibit List), Certificate of Service. Exhibits 1-37 are being mailed due to size.
275 08-26-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Pre-Hearing Memorandum (Hearing Exhibits to be mailed)
276 08-27-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia's Motion for Site View
277 08-27-2014 Memorandum of Law in Support of Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion for Site View
278 08-28-2014 Exhibit 1 to Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia LLC's Motion for Site View
279 08-28-2014 Proposed Order - Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion for Site View
280 08-28-2014 DEP's Letter and Pre-Hearing Memorandum Exhibits 1-37. (hard)
281 08-28-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Prehearing Memorandum Exhibits. (RR-1 through RR230/6 boxes)
282 08-28-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Strike Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Expert Reports and For Expedited Consideration Thereof
283 08-29-2014 ORDER: Responses to Range's Motion for Site View, if any, shall be filed on or before September 3, 2014.
284 08-29-2014 ORDER: Following review of Appellant's Motion to Strike Range Resources' Expert Report and Rebuttal Expert Reports, responses and memoranda of law, if any, shall be filed on or before September 3, 2014.
285 09-02-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION FOR DETERMINATION OF SCOPE OF REBUTTABLE PRESUMPTION AND FOR ENTRY OF AN ORDER DIRECTING APPELLANT TO DISCLOSE ALLEGED CONTAMINANTS IN HIS WATER SUPPLY: It is ordered that the motion is denied.
286 09-02-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON RANGE RESOURCES-APPALACHIA, LLC'S MOTION TO COMPEL SAMPLING OF APPELLANT'S WATER SUPPLY: It is ordered that the motion to compel is denied.
287 09-03-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's Response to Permittee's Motion for Site View with Memorandum in Support and Proof of Service
288 09-03-2014 DEP's Letter, Response to Appellant's Motion to Strike Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Expert Report and Rebuttal Expert Reports, Memorandum in Support thereof, and Certificate of Service.
289 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion in Limine to Exclude Scientific Evidence Regarding Auto Salvage Yard and Memorandum of Law in Support
290 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion in Limine to Exclude Any Evidence that Appellant's Water is not Polluted and that Three Compounds were due to Laboratory Contamination and Memorandum of Law in Support
291 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of Criminal Record and Memorandum of Law in Support
292 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence from Range Resources Supplemental Production of August 22, 2014 and Memorandum of Law in Support
293 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion in Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony and Expert Report of A. Elizabeth Perry, P.G. and Memorandum of Law in Support
294 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion in Limine to Exclude the Testimony of John F. Stolz and Memorandum of Law in Support
295 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion in Limine to Exclude the Testimony of Representatives from Consolidation Coal Company and Universal Well Services and Memorandum of Law in Support
296 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion in Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony Regarding Grace Kiskadden's Water Well as Being Hydrologically Isolated from the Yeager Site and Memorandum of Law in Support
297 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion in Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony and Expert Reports of the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection and Memorandum of Law in Support
298 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion in Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony of Dr. Crystal G. Morrison, Bo Valli and Dr. James Pinta and the RJ Lee Group Report and Memorandum of Law in Support
299 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Response in Opposition to Range Resources' Motion for Site View and Memorandum of Law in Support
300 09-03-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion to Strike Expert Report and Rebuttal Expert Reports and for Expedited Consideration Thereof
301 09-03-2014 Memorandum of Law in Support of Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion to Strike Expert Report and Rebuttal Expert Reports and for Expedited Consideration Thereof
302 09-03-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Motion to Strike the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection's and Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Conclusions and Determinations Regarding the Origin of Methane in Mr. Kiskadden's Water Including all Evidence, Testimony and Expert Opinion Regarding the Same and Memorandum of Law in Support
303 09-03-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion to Exclude Expert Testimony Based on Methodology Lacking General Acceptance in the Scientific Community
304 09-03-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion to Exclude Expert Testimony Based on Methodology Lacking General Acceptance in the Scientific Community
305 09-03-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence or Argument Concerning Certain Alleged Releases at or Near the Yeager Site
306 09-03-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence or Argument Concerning Certain Alleged Releases at or Near the Yeager Site
307 09-03-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence or Argument Concerning "Pollutants" that Fail to Exceed Maximum Contaminant Levels Under The Pennsylvania Safe Drinking Water Act
308 09-03-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence or Argument Concerning "Pollutants" that Fail to Exceed Maximum Contaminant Levels Under The Pennsylvania Safe Drinking Water Act
309 09-03-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence or Argument Concerning the Alberta, Canada Incident
310 09-03-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence or Argument Concerning the Alberta, Canada Incident
311 09-04-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON PERMITTEE'S MOTION FOR SITE VIEW: It is ordered that Range's motion for a site view is granted. An order scheduling the date of the site will be issued separately.
312 09-05-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's Response to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence on Criminal Record with Memorandum in Support and Certificate of Service
313 09-05-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's Response to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Scientific Evidence Regarding the Salvage Yard, Memorandum in Support and Certificate of Service
314 09-05-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's Response to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Any Evidence That Appellant's Water Is Not Polluted and That Three Compounds Were Due to Laboratory Contamination, Memorandum of Law in support and Certificate of Service
315 09-05-2014 ORDER: Permittee's motion in limine to exclude evidence or argument concerning the Alberta, Canada Incident is denied.
316 09-05-2014 ORDER: Appellant's motion in limine to exclude any evidence that appellant's water is not polluted and that three compounds were due to laboratory contamination is denied.
317 09-08-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's letter responding to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence from Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Supplemental Production of August 22, 2014
318 09-08-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's letter Response to Appellant's Motion to Exclude Expert Testimony of Dr. Crystal G. Morrison, Bo Valli and Dr. James Pinta and the RJ Group Report
319 09-08-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's letter responding to Appellant's Motion to Exclude Testimony of Representatives From Consolidation Coal Company and Universal Well Services,Inc.
320 09-08-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's letter responding to Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Motion to Exclude Expert Testimony Based on Methodologies Lacking General Acceptance in the Scientific Community
321 09-08-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's letter regarding Appellant's Motion to Exclude Expert Testimony and Expert Report of A. Elizabeth Perry, P.G.
322 09-08-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's letter responding to Appellant's Motion to Exclude the Testimony of John F. Stoltz
323 09-08-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's Response to Permittee Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence or Argument Concerning Certain Alleged Releases at or Near the Yeager Site
324 09-08-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's Response to Appellant's Motion to Strike the Department of Environmental Protection's and Range Resources - Appalachia, LLC's Conclusions and Determinations Regarding the Origin of Methane in Mr. Kiskadden's Water Including All Evidence, Testimony and Expert Opinion Regarding the same, with Memorandum in Support
325 09-09-2014 DEP's Letter, Response to Appellant's Motion In Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony Regarding Grace Kiskadden's Water Well as Being Hydrologically Isolated from the Yeager Site, Memorandum of Law in Support thereof, and Exhibits A-C (due to size, Exhibits A-C are being placed in today's mail).
326 09-09-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of Criminal Record
327 09-09-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of Criminal Record
328 09-10-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Response in Opposition to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony Regarding Grace Kiskadden's Water Well as Being Hydrologically Isolated From the Yeager Site with Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Appellant's Motion
329 09-10-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude the Testimony of John F. Stolz with Response to Appellant's Memorandum of Law In Support
330 09-10-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Response in Opposition to Motion to Strike Conclusions and Determinations Regarding the Origin of Methane in Mr. Kiskadden's Water with Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Appellant's Motion
331 09-10-2014 DEP's Response to Permittee's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence or Argument Concerning "Pollutants" that fail to Exceed Maximum Contaminant Levels under the Pennsylvania Safe Drinking Water Act, Memorandum in Support thereof, and Certificate of Service.
332 09-10-2014 Appellant's Response in Opposition to Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence or Argument Concerning "Pollutants" that Fail to Exceed Maximum Contamination Levels Under the Pennsylvania Safe Drinking Water Act
333 09-10-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's Response to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony and Expert Reports of the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection with Memorandum in Support
334 09-10-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE EXPERT TESTIMONY REGARDING GRACE KISKADDEN'S WATER WELL AS BEING HYDROLOGICALLY ISOLATED FROM THE YEAGER SITE: It is ordered that the motion in limine is denied.
335 09-10-2014 ORDER: Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony and Expert Reports of the Department. It is ordered...1. The various objections raised by Appellant are denied without prejudice and may be raised at the hearing in this case and 2. The expert reports filed in this case will not be admitted into evidence during the hearing.
336 09-10-2014 Appellant's Response in Opposition to Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia LLC's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence or Argument Concerning Certain Alleged Releases at or Near the Yeager Site
337 09-10-2014 Appellant's Response in Opposition to Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia LLC's Motion in Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony Based on Methodology Lacking General Acceptance in the Scientific Community
338 09-10-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Scientific Evidence Regarding Auto Salvage Junkyard with Memorandum of Law in Support
339 09-10-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude the Testimony of Dr. Crystal G. Morrison, Bo Valli and Dr. James Pinta and the RJ Lee Group Report with Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Appellant's Motion
340 09-10-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Response in Opposition to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence from Range's Supplemental Production of August 22, 2014 with Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Appellant's Motion
341 09-10-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Testimony of Representatives from Consolidated Coal Company and Universal Well Services, Inc. with Memorandum of Law in Support
342 09-10-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony and Expert Report of A. Elizabeth Perry with Memorandum of Law in Support
343 09-11-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON APPELLANT'S MOTION TO STRIKE THE DEPARTMENT'S AND RANGE'S CONCLUSIONS AND DETERMINATIONS REGARDING THE ORIGIN OF METHANE IN APPELLANT'S WATER: It is ordered that the motion to strike including all evidence, testimony and expert opinion regarding the same is denied.
344 09-11-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE EXPERT TESTIMONY OF JOHN STOLTZ: It is ordered that the motion in limine is denied.
345 09-11-2014 Department's [Exhibits A-C] to its Response to Appellant's motion in limine to exclude expert testimony regarding Grace Kiskadden's water well as being hydrologically isolated from the Yeager Site.
346 09-12-2014 Department of Environmental Protection's Letter Regarding Order of Proof
347 09-12-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE EXPERT TESTIMONY BASED ON METHODOLOGIES LACKING GENERAL ACCEPTANCE IN THE SCIENTIFIC COMMUNITY: It is ordered that the motion in limine is denied.
348 09-12-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON APPELLANT'S MOTION TO STRIKE EXPERT REPORTS AND EXPERT REBUTTAL REPORTS: It is ordered that the motion is granted.
349 09-15-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON APPELLANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE TESTIMONY OF REPRESENTATIVES FROM CONSOLIDATION COAL COMPANY AND UNIVERSAL WELL SERVICES, INC.: It is ordered that the motion in limine is granted in part and denied in part, as set forth in our Opinion.
350 09-15-2014 Permittee's "Exhibit 3" (cd rom and hard copy) to its Memorandum of Law in Support of its response to Appellant's motion in limine to exclude scientific evidence regarding auto salvage Yard (efiled on September 10, 2014).
351 09-15-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON APPELLANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF CRIMINAL RECORD: It is ordered: 1) Counsel for Range shall either bring a copy of the criminal record to the prehearing conference on September 16, 2014 or file it electronically under seal. 2) Board will rule on the admissibility of the criminal record at the prehearing conference.
352 09-15-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON APPELLANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE EXPERT TESTIMONY AND EXPERT REPORT OF A. ELIZABETH PERRY, P.G.: It is ordered: 1) Appellant's motion to exclude Ms. Perry's expert testimony is denied.
353 09-15-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON APPELLANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF DR. CRYSTAL G. MORRISON, BO VALLI AND DR. JAMES PINTA AND THE RJ LEE GROUP REPORT: It is ordered: 1) Appellant's motion to exclude the testimony of Dr. James Pinta, who has been withdrawn as a witness by Range Resources after the filing of the motion is granted. 2) Appellant's motion to exclude the testimony of Dr. Morrison and Mr. Valli will be taken under advisement.
354 09-15-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Petition for Reconsideration of the Environmental Hearing Board's Opinion and Order on Appellant's Motion to Strike Expert Report and Rebuttal Expert Reports with Memorandum of Law in Support
355 09-16-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON APPELLANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE REGARDING AUTO SALVAGE YARD: It is ordered that the motion is denied.
356 09-16-2014 ORDER: 1) All requests by the parties and media to video record the court proceedings in this matter are denied; 2) All requests for still photography in the courtroom are denied; 3) All requests to audio record the court proceedings in this matter are denied; 4) All requests to video record the site view in this matter are denied.
357 09-16-2014 ORDER: It is ordered 1) the Department will present its case in chief first; 2) This does not change the burden of proof or any other burdens in this case.
358 09-16-2014 ORDER: 1) Range's request to have its own court reporter to provide it with daily unofficial transcripts is granted; 2) Range's court reporter shall sit at or behind counsel table; 3) Range's court reporter's transcript is not an official transcript; 4) If use of two court reporters becomes disruptive, the Board may rescind its order.
359 09-17-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON PERMITTEE'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT CONCERNING "POLLUTANTS" THAT FAIL TO EXCEED MAXIMUM CONTAIMINANT LEVELS UNDER PA SAFE DRINKING WATER ACT: It is ordered that the motion is denied.
360 09-17-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON PERMITTEE'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT CONCERNING CERTAIN ALLEGED RELEASES AT OR NEAR YEAGER SITE: It is ordered that the motion is denied.
361 09-18-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Letter to Judge Renwand regarding Permittee's Corrected Hearing Exhibit RR-102
362 09-18-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Response in Opposition to Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Petition for Reconsideration of the Environmental Hearing Board's Opinion and Order on Appellant's Motion to Strike Expert Report and Rebuttal Expert Reports
363 09-19-2014 ORDER: Appellant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of Criminal Record is granted.
364 09-19-2014 ORDER: The hearing in this matter will start each day at 9:30 am unless further modified by the Board.
365 09-19-2014 Appellant's Motion to Exclude Range Resources' Use of Hydraulic Fracturing Animation
366 09-22-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON RANGE-RESOURCES-APPALACHIA, LLC'S PETITION FOR RECONSIDERATION OF THE BOARD'S OPINION AND ORDER ON APPELLANT'S MOTION TO STRIKE EXPERT REPORT AND REBUTTAL EXPERT REPORTS: It is ordered that the petition for reconsideration is denied.
367 09-22-2014 DEP's letter regarding scheduling of witnesses Upadhyay and Kiskadden
368 09-22-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Response to Appellant's Motion to Exclude Range Resources' Use of Hydraulic Fracturing Animation with Memorandum of Law in Support
369 09-26-2014 ORDER: 1) The request of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette to have a member of the press attend the site view scheduled for Friday, September 26, 2014 is granted; 2) All requests for permission to take still photography during the site view are denied; 3) All requests for permission to take audio or visual recordings during the site view are denied; 4) Other members of the Press may also attend the site view at the discretion of the Board and in accordance with the provisions of this Order; 5) The site view is not evidence in the case and no testimony will be taken; 6) Those attending the site view will meet at the offices of Range Resources, Southpoint, Canonsburg, PA at 10:00 AM on Friday, September 26, 2014.
370 10-02-2014 ORDER: Additional hearing dates are required. 1) the Board will conduct hearings in Pittsburgh on October 15, 16, 17, 31 and November 3, 2014. 2) The hearing on October 15, 2014 will begin at 11:00 AM; all other days will begin at 9:30 AM.
371 10-14-2014 ORDER: 1) The hearing dates of October 31, 2014 and November 3, 2014 are cancelled; 2) The hearing dates of November 5, 6, 7, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, and 24, 2014 are added; 3) The hearing will begin at 9:30 AM each day.
372 10-14-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion for Leave to File Rebuttal Expert Reports and Present Rebuttal Expert Testimony with Memorandum of Law in Support
373 10-14-2014 (ERRATA FILING)Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion for Leave to File Rebuttal Expert Reports and Present Rebuttal Expert Testimony
374 10-14-2014 Transcripts received (Adelman Reporters): Hearings held on September 23, 24, 25, 30, 2014 and October 1 and 2, 2014 in Pittsburgh. (Original and condensed versions)
375 10-15-2014 ORDER: Responses to Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion for Leave to File Rebuttal Expert Reports and Present Rebuttal Expert Testimony, if any, shall be filed on October 21, 2014.
376 10-21-2014 DEP's Response to Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion for leave to File Rebuttal Expert Reports and Present Rebuttal Expert Testimony, and Certificate of Service.
377 10-21-2014 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Supplemental Submittal in Support of Motion for Leave to File Rebuttal Expert Reports and Present Rebuttal Expert Testimony with Exhibits 1-4
378 10-21-2014 Appellant Kiskadden's Response in Opposition to Range Resources' Motion for Leave to File Rebuttal Expert Reports and Present Rebuttal Expert Testimony and Memorandum of Law
379 10-24-2014 Transcripts received (Adelman Reporters): Hearings held on October 3, 7, 8, and 9, 2014 in Pittsburgh. (Original and condensed versions)
380 11-06-2014 Transcripts received (Adelman Reporters): Hearings held on October 15, 16, and 17, 2014 in Pittsburgh. (Original and condensed versions)
381 11-10-2014 ORDER: The hearing dates of November 13, 2014 and November 14, 2014 have been added to the hearing schedule; the hearing will begin each day at 9:30 a.m. in Court Room 2014.
382 11-13-2014 Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion for Directed Adjudication
383 11-17-2014 ORDER: The Appellant Loren Kiskadden and the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection may respond to Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Motion for Directed Verdict in their Post Hearing Briefs.
384 11-19-2014 OPINION AND ORDER ON PERMITTEE RANGE RESOURCES-APPALACHIA, LLC'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE REBUTTAL EXPERT REPORTS AND PRESENT REBUTTAL EXPERT TESTIMONY: It is ordered that the motion is denied.
385 11-20-2014 ORDER: Following the conclusion of the hearing, it is ordered as follows: 1) Post Hearing Briefs shall be filed on or before January 30, 2015; 2) Reply Briefs shall be filed on or before March 18, 2015; 3) Reply Briefs should not exceed 50 pages.
386 12-09-2014 Transcripts received (Adelman Reporters): Hearings held on November 5, 6, 7, and 13, 2014 in Pittsburgh. (Original and condensed versions)
387 12-12-2014 Transcripts received (Adelman Reporters): Hearings held on November 14, 18, and 19, 2014 in Pittsburgh. (Original and condensed versions)
388 01-12-2015 DEP's Letter (with parties consent) requesting a two week extension for the parties due date for Post Hearing Briefs, proposed Order, and Certificate of Service.
389 01-13-2015 ORDER: Post Hearing Briefs for all parties shall be filed on or before February 13, 2015.
390 01-30-2015 ORDER: It is ordered...1) Post hearing briefs shall be filed on or before February 27, 2015; 2) Reply briefs shall be filed on or before April 17, 2015; 3) Reply briefs shall not exceed 50 pages.
391 02-27-2015 Department of Environmental Protection's Post-Hearing Brief
392 02-27-2015 Appellant Loren Kiskadden's Post Hearing Brief
393 02-27-2015 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Post-Hearing Brief with Exhibits A-D and Permittee Range Resources Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
394 03-17-2015 Exhibit E to Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Post-Hearing Brief
395 03-25-2015 ORDER: Reply briefs shall be filed on or before April 24, 2015.
396 04-24-2015 Department of Environmental Protection's Reply Brief
397 04-24-2015 Appellant Loren Kiskadden's Reply Brief to Department's Post-Hearing Brief
398 04-24-2015 Appellant Loren Kiskadden's Reply Brief to Range Resources Post-Hearing Brief
399 04-24-2015 Appellant Loren Kiskadden's Reply Brief to Department's Post-Hearing Brief
400 04-24-2015 Permittee Range Resources-Appalachia, LLC's Post-Hearing Reply Brief
401 06-12-2015 ADJUDICATION: It is ordered that the appeal filed by Mr. Loren Kiskadden is dismissed.
402 06-12-2015 ADJUDICATION: It is ordered that the appeal filed by Mr. Loren Kiskadden is dismissed.
403 07-14-2015 Copy of Petition for Review [on behalf of Loren Kiskadden] filed in Commonwealth Court.
404 07-15-2015 Copy of Notice of Filing Petition for Review" [Loren Kiskadden] filed in Commonwealth Court on July 9, 2015. [Cmwlth. Ct. No. 1167 CD 2015] Notice dated July 13, 2015. Certification of record due August 24, 2015.
405 08-12-2015 CERTIFICATION OF RECORD TO THE PROTHONOTARY, COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA: Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rules of Appellate Procedure 1541, 1951, and 1952, the Environmental Hearing Board hereby certifies the enclosed to be the true and correct record of its proceedings in this matter. (Cmwlth Ct. No. 1167 CD 2015)(Files/boxes picked up by UPS)
406 08-13-2015 Received in Commonwealth Court CERTIFICATION OF RECORD TO THE PROTHONOTARY, COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA: Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rules of Appellate Procedure 1541, 1951, and 1952, the Environmental Hearing Board hereby certifies the enclosed to be the true and correct record of its proceedings in this matter. (Cmwlth Ct. No. 1167 CD 2015)
407 08-27-2015 ORDER: Pursuant to Pa.R.A.P. 1952(c), the Environmental Hearing Board hereby advises counsel that the certified record in this matter has been transmitted to Commonwealth Court on August 12, 2015.
408 10-27-2016 Copy of the Opinion (by Judge Wojcik) and Order from Cmwlth Ct. dated October 26, 2016: The adjudication of the Environmental Hearing Board dated June 12, 2015 is affirmed. (Cmwlth Ct. No. 1167 CD 2015) along with Dissenting Opinion by Judge McCullough.
409 11-28-2016 Copy of Supreme Court [Western District]: Date Petition for Allowance of Appeal Filed on November 22, 2016. (No. 480 WAL 2016)
410 05-22-2017 Files returned from Commonwealth Court. (11 boxes)
411 05-23-2017 Copy of Supreme Court's Order dated May 2, 2017: The Petition for Allowance of Appeal is DENIED. (No. 480 WAL 2016).
412 05-24-2017 Copy of Supreme Court's Order dated May 2, 2017: The Petition for Allowance of Appeal is DENIED. (No. 480 WAL 2016). (scan)
413 11-20-2017 Records transferred to Record Center: EHB Box #1295 - Record Center Box #806286.
414 11-20-2017 Records transferred to Record Center: EHB Box #1296 - Record Center Box #806287.
415 11-20-2017 Records transferred to Record Center: EHB Box #1297 - Record Center Box #806288.
416 11-20-2017 Records transferred to Record Center: EHB Box #1298 - Record Center Box #806289.
417 11-20-2017 Records transferred to Record Center: EHB Box #1299 - Record Center Box #806290.
418 11-20-2017 Records transferred to Record Center: EHB Box #1300 - Record Center Box #806291.
419 11-20-2017 Records transferred to Record Center: EHB Box #1301 - Record Center Box #806292.
420 11-20-2017 Records transferred to Record Center: EHB Box #1302 - Record Center Box #806293.
421 11-20-2017 Records transferred to Record Center: EHB Box #1303 - Record Center Box #806294.