Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board: Coat of Arms The
Environmental Hearing Board



About Us

Hearing Schedule

Docket Search

Electronic Filing


Rules, Decisions, and Resources

EHB Rules Committee

Agency Open Records and "Right to Know" Law

Case Number: 2015027
Appellant #1: JUSTIN SNYDER
Appellant #3: MARIE COHEN
Appellant #4: ALEX LOTORTO
Appellant #5: GREG LOTORTO



# Filing Date Description Documents (?)
1 03-02-2015 Appeal of the Department's Air Quality Plan Approval 52-00001A to Columbia Gas Transmission, LLC regarding the Milford Compressor Station located in Milford Township, Pike County. Notice of the Plan Approval was published in the Pennsylvania Bulletin January 31, 2015. (fax)
2 03-03-2015 Notice of appeal.
3 03-03-2015 PREHEARING ORDER NO. 1: Discovery completed by August 31, 2015; joint statement regarding settlement conference April 27, 2015; dispositive motions filed by September 28, 2015.
4 03-03-2015 Notice of Appeal, with appendix. (e-file)
5 03-04-2015 AMENDED PREHEARING ORDER NO. 1: Amended order includes Robin Schneider as an appellant and changes permittee's address from West Virginia to New York. No other changes were made.
6 03-06-2015 Notice of Appeal, with appendix. (hard)
7 03-19-2015 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE: On behalf of the [Department] Sean L. Robbins, Office of Chief Counsel, Northeast Region, Wilkes-Barre.
8 03-20-2015 Copy of Attorney Alex Chiaruttini [PA Bar Association] letters to each of the Appellants requesting financial documents for their pro bono request.
9 03-23-2015 Appellant's [Robin Schneider] Signature Page.
10 03-23-2015 Appellant's [Robin Schneider] Signature Page. (scan)
11 03-23-2015 Amendment to the Notice of Appeal, filed by Alex Lotorto
12 03-24-2015 Supporting Document to Objection #6, Wilma Subra Presentation
13 03-26-2015 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE: On behalf of the [Permittee] Sondra A. Hemeryck, Esquire with Schiff Hardin LLP, Chicago, Il.
14 03-30-2015 Appellee Columbia Gas Transmission LLC Petition for Daniel J. Deeb and David M. Loring to Appear Pro Hac Vice
15 04-10-2015 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE: On behalf of the [Appellants] William Cluck, Esquire.
16 04-14-2015 Copy of Attorney Alexandra Chiaruttini letter dated April 9, 2015 to the [Appellant - Marie Liu] stating that pro bono counsel will not be provided.
17 04-20-2015 ORDER: Attorneys David M. Loring and Daniel Deeb are permitted to appear pro hac vice in this matter for Columbia Gas Transmission, LLC.
18 04-21-2015 Parties Joint Letter re settlement and e-discovery
19 04-21-2015 ORDER: A joint settlement statement and proposed electronic discovery plan shall be filed on or before May 15, 2015.
20 05-15-2015 Copies of letters to the Appellant's [Justin Snyder, Stephanie Snyder, Marie Cohen, Alexander Lotorto, Greg Lotorto, Bess Moran and Robin Schneider] from Attorney Alexandra Chiaruttini that their request for pro bono representation is incomplete and request file will be closed within the next five days.
21 05-15-2015 Extension of time
22 05-18-2015 ORDER: Filing a joint settlement statemant joint electronic discovery report are further extended to May 22, 2015.
23 05-22-2015 Joint Report Concerning the Discovery of Electronically Store Information and Joint Statement That Parties Have Conferred About Settlement
24 05-26-2015 ORDER: Electronic Discovery Plan filed by the parties, the filing is approved as the electronic discovery plan for this case and all parties shall comply with its provisions.
25 08-18-2015 Parties joint letter requesting extension of deadlines
26 08-19-2015 ORDER: Discovery completed by November 24, 2015; dispositive motions filed by December 23, 2015.
27 10-13-2015 Permittee Columbia Gas Transmission LLC's Motion to Dismiss and Memorandum in Support.
28 10-14-2015 Permittee Columbia Gas Transmission LLC's Motion to Dismiss and Memorandum in Support (w/exhibits). hard
29 10-27-2015 DEP's Memorandum of Law in Response to Columbia Gas's Motion to Dismiss
30 11-16-2015 Joint request to extend deadlines
31 11-17-2015 ORDER: It is ordered: Discovery shall be completed by January 22, 2016; Dispositive motions shall be filed by February 22, 2016.
32 11-30-2015 Appellants Response to Columbia Gas' Motion to Dismiss
33 12-15-2015 Columbia Gas Transmission LLC's Reply to Appellants' Response to Columbia's Motion to Dismiss
34 12-21-2015 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION TO DISMISS: It is ordered that the Permittee's motion to dismiss is denied.
35 01-21-2016 Joint Letter Request for Extension of Discovery and Dispositive Motion Deadlines
36 01-22-2016 ORDER: 1) Discovery shall be completed by April 21, 2016. 2) Dispositive motions shall be completed by May 23, 2016.
37 02-24-2016 Permittee Columbia Gas Transmission LLC's Substitution of Appearance and Verified Statement
38 04-12-2016 Joint Request for Extension
39 04-13-2016 ORDER: 1) Discovery by June 6, 2016. 2) Dispositive motions by July 7, 2016.
40 06-14-2016 Praecipe for Appellants Bess Moran, Marie Liu and Robin Schneider to Withdraw
41 06-15-2016 ORDER: It is ordered that Bess Moran, Marie Liu and Robin Schneider may withdraw as appellants.
42 07-05-2016 Refiling request for extension of time for dispositive motion based on issue with e-filingsystem
43 07-06-2016 ORDER: Any dispositive motions filed by July 15, 2016.
44 07-15-2016 Appellants Summary Judgment package
45 08-10-2016 Joint Request for Extension of Time to File Response to Appellants' Motion for Summary Judgment
46 08-10-2016 ORDER: The deadline to file a response to the Appellants' Motion for Summary Judgment is Tuesday, August 23, 2016.
47 08-23-2016 Columbia Gas Transmission LLC's Response Package to Appellants' Motion for Summary Judgment
48 08-23-2016 DEP's Response to Appellants' Motion for Summary Judgment
49 09-07-2016 Appellants'Reply Brief
50 09-16-2016 OPINION AND ORDER ON MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT: Appellants' motion for summary judgment is denied.
51 09-30-2016 PRE-HEARING ORDER NO. 2: Hearing scheduled for Monday, March 13, 2017 at 10:00 a.m. and continuing thereafter at the EHB Harrisburg offices. (Commonwealth Reporting Co., Inc.) Immediately following the conclusion of this hearing, a hearing will commence in Mamrak et al. v. DEP and Columbia Gas Transmission, LLC EHB Docket 2015-080-L. 1) Appellants' pre-hearing memo due by Tuesday, January 24, 2017; 2) Department's and Permittee's pre-hearing memos due by Friday, February 17, 2017. 3) Factual stipulations must be filed with the Board 5 days before hearing date.
52 12-29-2016 Appellants' Praecipe to Withdraw Notice of Appeal
53 12-29-2016 ORDER: Appeal withdrawn closed and discontinued. The hearing scheduled for March 13, 2017 is cancelled. (Commonwealth Reporting Co. Inc.)
54 11-20-2017 Records transferred to Record Center: EHB Box #1293 - Record Center Box #806284